UPDATED SEPTEMBER 3, 2013 9:59 PM
When Movies Trade on Real Life
DEBATERS
Being True Is Hard Work PAMELA KATZ, SCREENWRITER
One must be accurate about someone’s life. But if you don’t illuminate something essential about their life, work and personality, you fail to tell the truth.
From Little Truth, a Bigger Truth AISHA HARRIS, SLATE
Inventing most of its characters and plot lines, “Lee Daniels’ The Butler” turns a benign life into a symbol of an epic struggle.
Manipulate History? So Did Shakespeare ROBERT B. TOPLIN, HISTORIAN
Cinematic historians exercise a good deal of artistic license because they make stories entertaining and understandable.
Filmmakers Have a Duty to Be Honest PAUL BYRNES, CRITIC
It’s foolish to assume no one will check a fact on the Internet. We all deserve a higher standard of truth.
A Blurred Line Between Fact and Fiction MOLLY HASKELL, CRITIC
Filmmakers need to have more faith in viewers, and viewers need to be more skeptical about filmmakers.
INTRODUCTION
This seems to be the year of the fact-based movie. After “Argo,” “Lincoln” and “Zero Dark Thirty“ dominated the Oscar buzz last year, more movies are based on or inspired by true stories. “Fruitvale Station” tells of the 2009 shooting of a young man by an Oakland transit officer and “Captain Phillips” will recount a merchant ship’s capture by Somali pirates. Other films out or coming out this year are based on the lives of Steve Jobs, Julian Assangeand Linda Lovelace. Often, in these films, accuracy is sacrificed for drama. But do the makers of films claiming to be based on or inspired by real stories have an allegiance to the truth, or just to the art of storytelling?
Read more of this post