Cities as ideas; founding visions are vulnerable. The more their realisation depends on the will and power of a single leader (or a colonial power), the more likely they are to be subverted
April 13, 2013 Leave a comment
Cities as ideas
When Peter the Great visited Amsterdam in 1697, he was dazzled. It was the richest city in the world, a maritime superpower and a global trade hub — confirmation of the West’s superiority in technology, education and the arts.
Amy Bernstein is the editor of Harvard Business Review.
20 HOURS 22 MIN AGO
When Peter the Great visited Amsterdam in 1697, he was dazzled. It was the richest city in the world, a maritime superpower and a global trade hub — confirmation of the West’s superiority in technology, education and the arts.
The contrast between the brilliance and worldliness of Amsterdam and the dreariness and xenophobia of his own capital, Moscow, was not to be borne. He wanted an Amsterdam of his own. So he built one.
As Daniel Brook describes in A History of Future Cities, St Petersburg was the czar’s bid to modernise (read: Westernise) his empire, and he supervised every detail of its construction. He brought in architects from Switzerland and Germany and engineers from England, Germany and Italy. He established the empire’s first secular, coeducational university and the world’s first public museum. He introduced his people to newspapers, salons and instrumental music concerts. In just a few years, St Petersburg grew into a model of European sophistication and a monument to its founder’s vision and audacity. Peter’s accomplishment, Brook argues persuasively, illustrates the notion that cities are “metaphors in steel and stone”. St Petersburg — along with Shanghai, Mumbai (formerly Bombay) and Dubai, the other three cities profiled in Brook’s engaging book — served as a gateway to the West. Through it, Peter imported non-native attitudes, approaches and behaviours in order to build the future.
But founding visions are vulnerable. The more their realisation depends on the will and power of a single leader (or a colonial power), the more likely they are to be subverted. And cities founded on ideas can suddenly, sometimes violently, come to represent entirely different ones. St Petersburg, Shanghai and Mumbai, for example, all turned against the West. Read more of this post







