Return of the living dead, hedge fund edition
October 5, 2013 Leave a comment
Return of the living dead, hedge fund edition
| Oct 03 10:51 | 10 comments | Share
We interrupt this blog to announce a zombie apocalypse has occurred. Please remain calm and do not adjust your allocations, many hedge funds remain open and fee structures are intact.
There are a lot of smart hedge fund managers out there, as well as a lot that are mediocre, lucky, or winging it. But it turns out they are outnumbered by the ranks of the discontinued, the dead, and the disappeared by almost two to one. Those numbers come to us via the Imperial College Centre for Hedge Funds Research, specifically a paper from last year revisiting “stylised facts” about hedge funds. It came to our attention after we wrote about a difficult comparison with the US stock market that many hedge funds will face in the new year. The UK’s Alternative Investment Management Association responded to our post citing the industry’s 20 year track record: Figures from Imperial College’s Centre for Hedge Research show the industry has generated over 4 per cent per annum of “alpha” or performance above the market, after fees. Very impressive, if you think there is such a thing as a 20 year track record for hedge funds that is relevant to the $2trn industry as it stands today. We do not, for a variety of reasons starting with the zombie hordes above. The academics at Imperial College put together data from the five major hedge fund databases, in order to avoid biases in individual data sets and to account for the fact that 70 per cent of hedge funds only report to one data provider. We document that the number of hedge funds ranges across data vendors from 6,772 for Morningstar to 9,719 for BarclayHedge. EurekaHedge is the largest data vendor in terms of 4,452 active hedge funds. Importantly, the proportion of alive and defunct funds varies significantly across databases. BarclayHedge, HFR and TASS (EurekaHedge and Morningstar) contain relatively more (fewer) defunct funds than alive funds. Read more of this post